Side · starch
Buttermilk Mashed Potatoes
Yukon Golds started in cold water, steamed dry, and mashed with butter first and tangy buttermilk second.

Ingredients · 4 servings
| 2 lb | Yukon Gold potatoes |
| 4 tbsp | unsalted butter |
| 0.75 cup | buttermilk |
| 1 tsp | kosher salt · pantry |
| 0.25 tsp | black pepper · pantry |
Method
- Cover the potatoes with cold water by an inch in a large pot and salt it generously. Bring to a boil, then simmer 15-18 minutes, until a knife slides in with no resistance.
- Drain well. Return the potatoes to the hot pot over low heat 1 minute, shaking, until the surface moisture steams off.
- Off the heat, mash with the butter until it is fully worked in.
- Stir in the buttermilk, salt, and pepper until creamy. Do not return the pot to the heat.
Nutrition · per serving
Estimated from this recipe's ingredients, not lab-measured — not a substitute for professional dietary advice.
Advertisement
The Why · No Anecdotes
The science, not a story about my childhood.
Why start the potatoes in cold water?
Dropped into boiling water, the outside of each chunk overcooks and starts to fall apart before heat reaches the center. Starting cold brings the whole piece up together, so it is evenly tender when it is done.
Why butter before buttermilk?
Mashing breaks open cooked starch granules. Free starch plus water makes glue. Working fat in first coats that starch so it cannot absorb as much liquid, which keeps the mash fluffy when the buttermilk goes in.
Why keep the pot off the heat after the buttermilk?
Buttermilk is acidic, and its proteins clump when heated near a simmer. In a mash that shows up as a grainy texture and a watery edge. The residual heat of the potatoes warms it enough.