NothingWilts

Entrée

Weeknight Butter Chicken

Yogurt-marinated chicken thighs browned in butter, then simmered in a spiced tomato-cream sauce. Fifteen-minute marinade.

Browned chicken pieces in a creamy orange tomato sauce with cilantro and white basmati rice
Active25 min
Total45 min
Dishes3
Per serving$2.40

Ingredients · 4 servings

1.5 lbboneless, skinless chicken thighs
0.5 cupplain whole-milk yogurt
1 tbspgaram masala
1 tspground cumin · pantry
0.5 tspground turmeric · pantry
0.25 tspcayenne pepper · pantry
1.25 tspkosher salt · pantry
3 tbspunsalted butter
1 smallyellow onion
1 tbspginger grow it ↗
4 clovesgarlic grow it ↗
1 15-oz cancrushed tomatoes
1 tspsugar · pantry
0.5 cupheavy cream
1.5 cupsbasmati rice · pantry
0.25 cupcilantro grow it ↗

Method

The chef moveCook the tomato base until the fat visibly separates at the edges — that is when the raw, tinny edge is gone.
  1. Toss the chicken with the yogurt, half of the garam masala, the cumin, turmeric, cayenne, and salt. Marinate 15 minutes at room temperature, or up to 8 hours refrigerated. Start the rice according to the package.
  2. Melt 1 tablespoon of the butter in a large skillet over medium-high heat. Shake the excess marinade off the chicken and brown it in a single layer, 3 minutes per side. Transfer to a plate; it will not be cooked through.
  3. Reduce the heat to medium and melt the remaining butter. Cook the onion 5 minutes, until soft. Add the ginger, garlic, and remaining garam masala and stir 45 seconds.
  4. Add the tomatoes and sugar and simmer 8 minutes, stirring, until thick and the butter separates at the edges.
  5. Stir in the cream, return the chicken and its juices, and simmer 6-8 minutes, until the chicken reads at least 165°F / 74°C.
  6. Top with cilantro and serve over the rice.

Nutrition · per serving

Calories705
Protein42g
Fat28g
Carbs68g
Fiber3g
Sodium760mg

Estimated from this recipe's ingredients, not lab-measured — not a substitute for professional dietary advice.

Advertisement

The Why · No Anecdotes

The science, not a story about my childhood.

What does a yogurt marinade do that a vinegar one does not?

Yogurt is only mildly acidic, so it loosens the surface proteins of the meat without tightening them into the chalky texture a strong acid causes. Its milk sugars and proteins also brown fast in the pan, which is where the dark, savory spots come from.

Why wait for the fat to separate from the tomatoes?

Fat and water stay mixed while there is plenty of water in the pan. When enough has evaporated, the butter pools at the edges. That is a visible sign the tomatoes have concentrated and their harsh raw acidity has cooked off.

Why add sugar to a savory sauce?

Canned tomatoes are noticeably acidic. A teaspoon of sugar does not make the sauce sweet; it offsets the sourness so the spices and cream come forward. Restaurant versions do the same thing, usually with more.

Suggested sides — swap freely